AsiaTEFL Logo
AsiaTEFL MENU
Indexed in SCOPUS
About AsiaTEFL
Notice
2023 Conference
Conference
Webinars
AsiaTEFL Book Series
AsiaTEFL Links
Gallery
The Journal of Asia TEFL
Information of the Journal
Submission Guidelines
Ethical Guidelines
Manuscript Submission
Editorial Board
Past Issues
Journal Order
Membership
Contact Us
My Page
Past Issues
Go List

Volume 15 Number 2, Summer 2018, Pages 257-565   


 http://dx.doi.org/10.18823/asiatefl.2018.15.2.11.429 PDF Download
   

Effectiveness of Teacher and Peer Feedback: Through the Lens of Korean Tertiary Writing Classroom

    Jeongyeon Park


This classroom-based research attempted to explore whether teacher and peer feedback can be effectively implemented in an EFL writing classroom at the tertiary level. Characteristics of teacher and peer feedback, students' use of feedback along with perceived usefulness, and complementing effects of teacher and peer feedback were analyzed. Twenty students enrolled in an academic writing course participated in the study. Students engaged in drafting, revising, and editing stages of writing under the process approach. Data gathered were essay drafts, a survey on teacher and peer feedback, and interviews. The study found that teacher and peer feedback included various categories (e.g., identification, suggestion) and areas (e.g., thesis, organization) of feedback, yet teacher feedback was more balanced than peer feedback. Students found both teacher and peer reviews helpful and recognized the benefits of each, but they favored and incorporated more of the teacher feedback. The interviews, however, revealed that most students appreciated peer feedback because they could learn new perspectives and expressions. Students also felt less obliged to accept all of peers' comments, compared to teachers' feedback, leading them to critically evaluate their usefulness. Active verbal interactions and in-depth trainings were suggested to make both types of feedback more meaningful.

Keywords: L2 writing, EFL, process writing, teacher feedback, peer feedback



JACET
KAFLE
KOTESOL
MELTA
ThaiTESOL
HAAL
TEFLIN
단체명 : AsiaTEFL (아시아영어교육학회)
고유번호 : 605-82-77130
소재지 : 광주광역시 광산구 호남대길 59, 1층 4101호
대표자 : 박주경
고객센터 : canteras@naver.com 043-230-3543 (09:00~18:00)