AsiaTEFL Logo
AsiaTEFL MENU
Indexed in SCOPUS
About AsiaTEFL
Notice
2023 Conference
Conference
Webinars
AsiaTEFL Book Series
AsiaTEFL Links
Gallery
The Journal of Asia TEFL
Information of the Journal
Submission Guidelines
Ethical Guidelines
Manuscript Submission
Editorial Board
Past Issues
Journal Order
Membership
Contact Us
My Page
Past Issues
Go List

Volume 7 Number 1, Spring 2010, Pages 1-393   


PDF Download
   

"Orientalism" and Contrastive (Intercultural) Rhetoric: A Response to What Said Has Said

    Deron Walker


Thirty years ago, Edward Said (1978) strongly criticized western scholars for "essentializing" the "exotic other." The "Orientalist" that Said described was complicit in a "discourse of power" that helped to enable Europe's exploitation of the Middle East and America's control over parts of the Far East. Postmodernists and post-colonialists of today share Said's concern with neo-colonialism and seek to protect others from harmful stereotypes. Meanwhile, the field initiated as contrastive rhetoric, now often called intercultural rhetoric, commenced when Kaplan (1966) discovered different organizational patterns in the English essays of five groups of international students. Though initially oversimplified, the field began with an explicitly pedagogical purpose: to help second language learners write better English academic essays. This paper will examine how Said-style criticism of "Orientalists," exercised by postmodernists and post-colonialists, has both helped to positively refine generalizations, biases and methodologies and simultaneously inhibited researchers and practitioners from further developing this pedagogically promising field of research in East-Asia.

Keywords: contrastive rhetoric, intercultural communication, intercultural rhetoric, Orientalism, postmodernism



JACET
KAFLE
KOTESOL
MELTA
ThaiTESOL
HAAL
TEFLIN
IGSE
단체명: AsiaTEFL (아시아영어교육학회)
고유번호: 605-82-77130
소재지: 광주광역시 광산구 호남대길 59, 1층 4101호
대표자: 박주경